top of page

文獻速遞(2022年11月-2023年1月)

Literature Database (Nov 2022-Jan 2023)

更新和匯總近期出版的平等權領域學術研究和實務報告

Update and compilation of recent academic research and reports in the area of equality rights

Gender-based Violence 性別暴力

Gender-based Violence 性別暴力

1. Sexual Assault 性侵犯

 

Luan, Hui, Guowei Wan, Xijuan Sun, Jialu Niu. “A Scoping Review of Programs to Prevent Child Sexual Abuse in Mainland China”

Trauma, Violence, & Abuse, 2022.

 

Abstract:

Child sexual abuse (CSA) is a worldwide public health concern. With the widespread dissemination of prevention approaches to end CSA, numerous CSA prevention programs exist in developed countries, but there is little evidence on how these programs are performing in Mainland China. The aim of this study was to review the existing research focusing on CSA prevention programs in Mainland China. Studies of CSA prevention programs were identified by conducting a comprehensive search of major academic databases for Chinese and English research. Articles were retained if they were original empirical studies that conducted programs to prevent CSA in Mainland China and measured related outcomes. Twelve studies met the inclusion criteria. A child-targeted, universally focused, and school-based educational program was the most common (n = 7), followed by specifically focused programs that covered migrant and left-behind children using group-based intervention strategies (n = 2) and ordinary parents with self-learning strategies (n = 2); one study delivered agency-based face-to-face education to parents with disabled children. However, the shortcomings in research design limited its replication to the broader population. CSA prevention program research in Mainland China is in an early stage due to the limited target populations, lack of large-scale government-led initiatives, and low involvement of multicomponent collaboration. We provide suggestions for conducting future research involving more inclusive programs for other populations, comprehensive programs with multiple targets and stakeholders, large-scale evidence-based research, culturally tailored and contextual adaptation programs.

_______________________________________

2. Sexual Harassment 性騷擾

Liu, Hong Yu. ““When Nobody Listens, Go Online”: The “807” Labor Movement Against Workplace Sexism in China's Tech Industry”

Gender, Work & Organization, Vol. 30, Issue 1, 2022, pp. 312-328.

 

Abstract:

An online petition, signed by more than six thousand Chinese tech workers in August 2021, is the latest example of an online labor movement in the authoritarian context of China. Combining interviews and publicly available information, this article provides a descriptive account of an activist movement, explains workers' demands, and discusses the characteristics of online labor activism. It explores how Chinese tech workers fight collectively against a gender-discriminatory workplace culture as they strive to bring justice to a sexual crime victim without affiliating themselves with official political organizations. The research findings suggest that while rising feminist consciousness has the potential to motivate collective action by workers, such motivation is highly dependent upon individual experiences at work and tends to be event-based and of limited continuity. It argues that rising awareness of women's rights provides a new kind of legitimacy to labor activism, and a new way to express labor concerns in a context of increased criminalization of labor organizational activities in China today.

Qiu, Geping, Honging Cheng. “Gender and Power in the Ivory Tower: Sexual Harassment in Graduate Supervision in China”

Journal of Gender Studies, 2022.

 

Abstract:

This article examines how female graduate students in China would perceive their experiences as survivors of sexual harassment by their faculty supervisors. Based on our narrative interviews at Chinese universities, this study has shown that 1) sexual harassment is the supervisor’s expression of gender-based power in Chinese academia; 2) instead of blatant coercion, harassers would use their power strategically to influence and manipulate the student’s ‘consent’ – that is, to lead the victim into deceived or illusory perceptions in order to sexually harass her; 3) for those participants who refused or resisted in particular, their academic progress, careers, health, relationships, and trust to society were all negatively affected; 4) a major cause of sexual harassment in the university setting was that female scholars and students were always treated in a sexual role rather than an academic role; and 5) institutional sexual harassment policies that deploy moral norms as a tool of attributing responsibility and blame can be seen as maintaining the very sexual hierarchies in the university settings.

_______________________________________

3. Domestic/Intimate Partner Violence 家庭/親密伴侶暴力

​​

Sun, Shufang et al. “Domestic Violence Victimization Among Men Who Have Sex with Men in China During the COVID-19 Lockdown”

Journal of interpersonal violence, Vol. 37, Issue 23-24, 2022, pp. NP22135-NP22150.

 

Abstract:

Many countries worldwide have implemented dedicated measures, such as shelter at home, to contain the spread of the COVID-19 virus. However, those mitigation measures may have major implications for individuals living with someone abusive or controlling. Domestic violence (DV) may be one of the unintended consequences of public health measures due to increased various stressors and reduced access to support and services. There has been a lack of empirical research on DV victimization among gender and sexual minorities, a population vulnerable to interpersonal violence and its associated adverse health outcomes. This study investigates the prevalence of DV victimization among men who have sex with men (MSM) in Jiangsu Province, China, during the COVID-19 lockdown and its correlates with COVID-19–related psychosocial and health stressors. A total of 413 MSM were recruited via snowball sampling, venue-based, and internet-based sampling from four cities in Jiangsu Province. After providing informed consent, all participants completed study questionnaires, followed by HIV testing. Over a quarter of the participants (27.4%) reported DV victimization during the COVID-19 lockdown, including experience of verbal, physical, or sexual abuse. After adjusting sociodemographic factors, DV victimization was associated with various adverse experiences during the COVID-19 lockdown, including increased stress or anxiety level, increased alcohol use, and housing instability. Study findings underscore the prevalence of DV victimization among MSM during the COVID-19 pandemic in China. The results can inform public health efforts to raise awareness and address DV victimization among MSM in the low- and middle-income country context during the COVID-19 pandemic. Adequate health and social services and economic resources are also critical to address the needs of MSM experiencing DV victimization.

付玉明、焦亞楠,家暴中弱勢方的緊急權確證:非對峙性反擊致死行為的非犯罪化研究

西南民族大學學報(人文社會科學版),2022年12期,第74-84頁。

 

摘要:

在當下社會中存在著大量的家庭暴力現象以及由此引發的傷害、致死案件。家暴受害者為了防止即將發生的家暴而實施的非對峙性反擊行為,入罪結論不符合社會情感和民眾期待,出罪結論則面臨法解釋論上的難題,即此種情形不符合正當防衛的時間要件。緊急權制度能夠保障緊急時刻公民的私力救濟權,維護婚姻家庭內部弱勢群體的合法權益,平衡“家暴情形”中夫妻雙方的權利關系。防御性緊急避險理論為家暴中非對峙性反擊致死行為提供了出罪的解釋空間及現實可能,但并非所有處于不法侵害尚未發生的危險狀態都符合防御性緊急避險對于危險程度的要求,應當將“正在發生的危險”理解為緊急的危險,而緊急性應根據隱蔽性危險與可視化危險的不同類別結合實際案情具體認定。實踐中,只有符合“緊急的危險”“不得已”“必要限度”“補充性”等要件的類型行為,才可以適用防御性緊急避險予以出罪化認定。

_______________________________________

4. Image-based Sexual Violence 影像性暴力

Crofts, Thomas. “Combatting Intimate Image Abuse in Hong Kong”

Hong Kong Law Journal, Vol. 52, Issue 2, 2022, pp. 405–430.

 

Abstract:

For some time, it has been recognised that intimate image abuse can cause significant harm to victims and that the existing criminal offences in Hong Kong were neither adequate nor appropriate to address such behaviour. To remedy this situation, four new offences were added to the Crimes Ordinance in October 2021. These offences cover voyeurism, unlawful recording of intimate images, publication of images unlawfully obtained and non-consensual publication of intimate images. This article explores the background to the new offences in Hong Kong, before critically and comparatively examining the elements of the new offences. In doing so, it contributes to the ongoing debate both in Hong Kong and overseas about how the criminal law can most appropriately respond to the harms caused by intimate image abuse.

Trafficking in Women and Girls 婦女和女童的人口販運

Trafficking

趙姍姍,收買被拐賣的婦女罪的法益追問與規范再造

法律科學(西北政法大學學報),2023年01期,第147-159頁。

 

摘要:

收買被拐賣的婦女罪直接侵害的法益為婦女的人格尊嚴,但本罪對人身自由、性自主權與個人發展權等合法權利具有抽象危險,應將這些權利納入本罪的法益范圍。當前實務部門對本罪處罰乏力的最主要原因并非執法不嚴,而在于《刑法》第241條的數罪并罰條款脫離了收買被拐賣的婦女罪的實踐特征,并且處罰力度受制于非法拘禁罪基本犯的規制盲區,致使處罰畸輕。收買被拐賣的婦女罪的規范再造應針對行為人的特征,通過提高法定刑,發揮刑罰的消極一般預防作用;以抽象危險作為基本犯中從重處罰的依據,以其他侵害作為數罪并罰的條件;遵循比例原則,將對個人發展權的侵害納入“情節嚴重”,在量刑時予以考量。

 

LGBT+ Rights 性小眾權利

LGBT

Chan, Randolph C.H., Janice Sin Yu Leung. “Monosexism as an Additional Dimension of Minority Stress Affecting Mental Health among Bisexual and Pansexual Individuals in Hong Kong: The Role of Gender and Sexual Identity Integration”

The Journal of Sex Research, 2022.

 

Abstract:

Monosexism has been increasingly recognized as a minority stressor uniquely experienced by plurisexual individuals. The present study investigated the effects of monosexist discrimination on mental health and examined the moderating role of gender and sexual identity integration (i.e., negation, authenticity, and disclosure). In a sample of 314 bisexual and pansexual individuals in Hong Kong (73.9% women and 26.1% men), the results showed that monosexist discrimination was associated with higher levels of depression and anxiety symptoms, above and beyond heterosexist discrimination. The association between monosexist discrimination and depression symptoms was stronger among bisexual and pansexual men than women, despite there being no gender differences in vulnerability to monosexist discrimination. Moreover, sexual identity negation, authenticity, and disclosure moderated the associations of monosexist discrimination with depression and anxiety symptoms, such that the associations were not significant among those with more positive integration of sexual identity (i.e., lower levels of sexual identity negation as well as higher levels of sexual identity authenticity and disclosure). This study provides insight into the deleterious impact of monosexism and the protective role of sexual identity integration. Implications for plurisexual-affirming psychological intervention, public policy, and community practice are discussed.

bottom of page